
Headlines are tricky. The tend to be short, usually just a couple of words, but much like design they are subjective (at least to some extent). Is the headline on your homepage the one your boss liked?...or is it a headline that actually works? Is it “kute with a k”?...or does it produce results? Stop guessing at what you think will work; it’s time to start testing your headlines!
First things first, make sure your it answers the following questions:
- Is the headline important?
- Is the headline relevant?
- Does the headline entice the user to click?...to continue browsing?...to do anything?!
Remember, just like the headline in a newspaper or magazine the sole purpose is to entice the user. The headline is the bait, everything that comes thereafter is the hook. You’ve only got a matter of seconds to fully engage them before they make the decision whether or not to hit the “Back” button.
So, where do you start? Begin by brainstorming a list of potential headlines that utilize different approaches, for example:
- Direct command – instruct the user what to do
- News related – inform the user about important information
- Question – ask the user for an answer
- List – explain to the user in an easy to read format
- How-to – educate the user, step-by-step
- Testimonial – show the user a specific example
- Teaser – inform the user in a playful manner
Take your new list, and narrow the headlines down to the ‘good ones’ and the ‘just ok’ (don’t worry, there’s no magic number). Those ‘good ones’ are the headlines you will be testing on your site.
Now before you get scared off...NO, you DO NOT need to manually change your headline every week.
Instead, you need to choose a website optimization tool to help you automate the process. There’s a multitude of choices, some more complicated than others, but the general idea is always the same. You put your headlines into the tool and the tool does all the legwork swapping headlines in-and-out on a user by user basis. Given time, the tool’s reporting will tell you what worked best, and which headlines to go with permanently.
It may sound a little tricky, maybe even a little overwhelming, but testing your headlines is a sure fire way to increase conversions using real stats.
Are you testing headlines on your site?
Image: To do



